homeabout kottke.orgarchives + tagsmembership!
aboutarchives + tagsmembership!

So here’s the answer to

posted by Jason Kottke   Feb 08, 2000

So here’s the answer to the three gunmen problem:

Gunman #1 should fire his shot into the air.

Want an explanation? Here’s the best one I received via email. Rob Cooper writes:

   This calls into question Game Theory — which was a cold-war think tank strategy on how to wage and win in very dire straits. Each should fire towards the most likely target. If #1 shoots #3 and hits, then he’s second shot in a two way. If he aims at #2 and hits, he’s second shot and sure to lose. If he fires his gun into the air, #2 will fire at #3. If #2 misses, and #3 hits, #1 gets to go first. If #2 hits #3, #1 gets to go first. Ergo, fire into the air, let the bad guys duke it out until you are first shot in a two-way contest.

   The worst thing #1 could do would be to aim at and hit his target in a 3 way contest — he’d most likely die. But if he aims and hits in a 2 way contest, he wins. In a 3 way contest — no one is shooting at him so it’s in his interest to keep it a 3 way contest until someone ELSE hits the other target.

Seems completely counterintuitive when you first hear the answer, but once you hear the explanation, it makes perfect sense.

We Work Remotely