Advertise here with Carbon Ads

This site is made possible by member support. ❤️

Big thanks to Arcustech for hosting the site and offering amazing tech support.

When you buy through links on kottke.org, I may earn an affiliate commission. Thanks for supporting the site!

kottke.org. home of fine hypertext products since 1998.

🍔  💀  📸  😭  🕳️  🤠  🎬  🥔

Cars Have Fucked Up This Country Bad. “On average, America is an ugly country. The median American scene…would be an exhaust-choked roadway flanked on both sides by fast food restaurants and big box stores.”

Discussion  13 comments

Ryan N

From the article:

Instead, I expect that America will undergo a long process, lasting much longer than my own lifetime, in which cities that are not built around cars will gradually expand and attract an ever-increasing share of the population, and the most thinly populated car-centric places will gradually decline in value, because they are just not nice places to live.

The street a half-block from my house (Lake Street in Uptown neighborhood of Minneapolis, Minnesota) is getting modified to be more multi-modal and the results have been fabulous:

  • Before: 4-lane one-way road with narrow sidewalks
  • After: 2-lane one-way road, protected bike lane, dedicated bus lane, wider sidewalks and generous bump-outs on each curb

The nearby street was one of the things I liked least about our house, and now it’s an asset. It's possible to change these car-centric places, but the change itself has been brutal — 1 year of major construction and lots of NIMBYism and pushback from neighbors.

Wade M

Minneapolis is absolutely a gem in terms of biking and pedestrian infrastructure. I lived there up until 4 years ago (in Uptown, just like you!) and I miss it dearly. My current city (Duluth MN) is pretty okay about bike/pedestrian support, but it's no Minneapolis and I'm finding myself riding my bike far less up here. The article's point about people being drawn to cities that move away from car-centricity in favor of livability rings true to me, I know I think often about moving back.

Ryan N

Minneapolis is absolutely a gem in terms of biking and pedestrian infrastructure.

Yes! Since moving to Minneapolis from Denver in 2022, I've been blown away by the biking infrastructure. It's rapidly getting better too. If my bike experiences are any indication, Minneapolis is comparable to famously bike-friendly cities like Copenhagen, Antwerp, and Seville. Time to move back, Wade!

Matt G

This is so encouraging to hear. We recently decided we’re going to move to the Twin Cities. In good portion of that decision is because of the acceptance of biking and walkability in general. Maybe that’s not every where yet, but at least the trajectory is very positive.

Jack Hays

I moved from MPLS, my hometown, about ten years ago, I too lived in Uptown and witnessed the very beginnings of the area taking itself back from the corporate BS that overtook it in the 00's, but whenever I go back to visit, I am astounded by the progress in that area.

Reply in this thread

Mark Reeves

For all the progress that the optimistic claim we're making with solar energy and transitions to clean energy I look around me and see everything pulling us in the opposite direction.

The obsession with cars—gas-powered cars and trucks—and ATV and dirt bike gas toys continues to grow unabated.

We've seen a new industry emerge around here in the supposedly enlightened capital of Vermont, consisting of men buying giant pickup trucks, to pull big trailers, to haul around giant lawnmowers, to mow half-acre suburban lots with. The noise, the fumes, the justification for owning death machine pickups. And everyone around me, including those pulling EVs into their driveways, are happy to subsidize this instead of using a little gas mower or electric mower for an hour once a week. My walls and floor shake when they show up to mow the lawn next door. It's the soundtrack to my life.

The neighbors now have someone dropping off and picking up kids driving some sort of giant diesel truck with a logo on the side. It idles for 10 minutes in their driveway or at the curb. It competes with the TV in my living room, doors and windows closed.

A once easy drive through VT to New York State, on narrow two-lane roads lined with rural homes, was recently officially opened up to tractor trailers creating a shipping corridor of cars backed up behind FedEx and Walmart shipments negotiating its twists and turns.

Tourists come in and out of the state with their pickup trucks hauling their gas toys.

It's ugly and it's rampant, and there's no stopping it.

Josh Fischel

I share your sentiment and experience. My wife's family shares a place down on the South Shore of Massachusetts, and gas-powered leaf blowers and lawnmowers are the relentless bird calls every week of the summer. We live in a deep-cut suburb of Boston, on a street with an uphill that conscience-free drivers like to zoom up in/on the loudest vehicles. They sometimes drown out reasonable-volume podcasts I'm listening to on headphones inside my home. I also teach at the nearby local public high school; traffic is always pretty nuts in the mornings, mostly because kids want bus-free autonomy and because parents would rather give their kid a lift than make them wait for the bus or encourage them to ride a bike. There's a boy who commutes to school aboard a unicycle, which warms my heart.

Reply in this thread

Bill Amstutz

The r/fuckcars subreddit has 450,000 members.
https://www.reddit.com/r/fuckcars/

Mike Akers

I think this channel has been mentioned on Kottke.org before, but the "Not Just Cars" YouTube channel is full of great videos about this topic. It's also added the word "stroad" to my vocabulary.

https://www.youtube.com/@NotJustBikes

Pete Ashton

Double thumbs up for Not Just Cars. I've learned a lot.

Reply in this thread

Colter Mccorkindale

Mathematically speaking, the "median scene" of this country would be empty pasture or forest. Humans don't even take up a majority of the U.S.'s real estate. And even if we limited the range to just towns and cities, the median scene would be a rural neighborhood scene of houses with side yards featuring minimal traffic. Yes, cars are annoying, but our infrastructure and housing stock are an incontrovertible fact. To remake our lives without cars would require us all to move into city centers and abandon unimaginably vast swaths of housing equity. Short of an extinction level event, it ain't happening.

Colter Mccorkindale

Besides: We're a nation of immigrants who don't trust each other and don't really want to live in close proximity to one another. It will take more than a century before smalltown citizens start trusting each other enough to give up their tiny kingdoms.

Reply in this thread

Tra H

As with most terrible things in the United States, we can trace the roots of this stroad ridden hellscape we all live in to that unholy, but extremely effective, union of corporate interest and racism.

Hello! In order to leave a comment, you need to be a current kottke.org member. If you'd like to sign up for a membership to support the site and join the conversation, you can explore your options here.

Existing members can sign in here. If you're a former member, you can renew your membership.

Note: If you are a member and tried to log in, it didn't work, and now you're stuck in a neverending login loop of death, try disabling any ad blockers or extensions that you have installed on your browser...sometimes they can interfere with the Memberful links. Still having trouble? Email me!