The Dangers of Elite Projection

posted by Jason Kottke Dec 16, 2022

Public transit consultant Jarrett Walker:

Elite projection is the belief, among relatively fortunate and influential people, that what those people find convenient or attractive is good for the society as a whole. Once you learn to recognize this simple mistake, you see it everywhere. It is perhaps the single most comprehensive barrier to prosperous, just, and liberating cities.

This is not a call to bash elites. I am making no claim about the proper distribution of wealth and opportunity, or about anyone's entitlement to influence. But I am pointing out a mistake that elites are constantly at risk of making. The mistake is to forget that elites are always a minority, and that planning a city or transport network around the preferences of a minority routinely yields an outcome that doesn't work for the majority. Even the elite minority won't like the result in the end.

He's talking about transit and cities, but you can see elite projection everywhere — like in social networks.